Friday, 26 October 2012
Constrained parametric model for simultaneous inference of two cumulative incidence functions
Haiwen Shi, Yu Cheng and Jong-Hyeon Jeong have a new paper in Biometrical Journal. This paper is somewhat similar in aims to the pre-print by Hudgens, Li and Fine in that it is concerned with parametric estimation in competing risks models. In particular, the focus is on building models for the cumulative incidence functions (CIFs) but ensuring that the CIFs sum to less than 1 at the asymptote as time tends to infinity. Hudgens, Li and Fine dealt with interval censored data but without covariates. Here, the data are assumed to be observed up to right-censoring but the emphasis is on simultaneously obtaining regression models directly for each CIF in a model with two risks.
The approach taken in the current paper is to assume that the CIFs will sum to 1 at the asymptote, to model the cause 1 CIF using a modified three-parameter logistic function with covariates via an appropriate link function. The CIF for the second competing risk is assumed to also have a three-parameter logistic form, but covariates only affect this CIF through the probability of this risk ever occurring.
When a particular risk in a competing risks model is of primary interest, the Fine-Gray model is attractive because it makes interpretation of the covariate effects straightforward. The model of Shi et al seems to be for cases where both risks are considered important, but still seems to require that one risk be considered more important. The main danger of the approach seems to be that the model for the effect of covariates on the second risk may be unrealistic, but will have an effect on the estimates for the first risk. If we only care about the first risk the Fine-Gray model would be a safer bet. If we care about both risks it might be wiser to choose a model based on the cause-specific hazards, which are guaranteed to induce a model with well behaved CIFs albeit at the expense of some interpretability of the resulting CIFs.
Obtaining a model with a direct CIF effect for each cause seems an almost impossible task because, if we allow a covariate to effect the CIF in such a way that a sufficiently extreme covariate leads to a CIF arbitrarily close to 1, it must be having a knock-on effect on the other CIF. The only way around this would be to have a model that assigns maximal asymptote probabilities to the CIFs at infinity that are independent of any covariates e.g. where are increasing functions taking values in [0,1] and . The need to restrict the to be independent of covariates would make the model quite inflexible however.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment